Burying the Dead at Bull Run

We arrived at Washington that evening, had some coffee and hard tack, crossed the Potomac River and went into camp for the first night at Arlington, Virginia.  It was raining.

Next morning President Lincoln came to the camp to ask us to do him a great favor; to go under a flag of truce to the battlefield of Bull Run to cover some three thousand dead boys whose bodies had lain in the hot sun for six days.  We would have three days time to do the work in and be off the battlefield or go to some Rebel prison.

The battle had taken place August 28th and 29th.1)Conrad’s dates do not always correspond with other sources.  He was writing this more than 50 years after the fact.  We arrived September 3rd at night.  The Confederates held the field.  It surely was some job for us boys.  It was hard for me to believe that so many dead men could lie on a front of four miles, and yet I was to see much worse.  Our dead had been robbed by the Rebels; they had no clothes.

About four hundred of our regiment took sick and were unfit for work.  It was terrible.  One sergeant in Company I, was playing off sick and our Captain reduced him to ranks and placed me in charge of his men.  To tell the truth I felt some sick myself, but I did not want to be called a coward.

~ Conrad Smith2)My Early Life and The Civil War, Conrad Smith, 1920 pg 23

The dead in the battle of Bull run were still unburied, and this regiment was sent to the field under flag of truce to perform the mournful duty of consigning them to the earth.  For three days it was incessantly employed.  Several days had now elapsed since the dead had fallen, the battle having commenced on the 27th of August, and the corpses exposed to a summer sun were in a loathsome condition.  Very few of the rebel dead had been left unburied, but the Union soldiers lay as they fell, scattered over all the field in every conceivable position.  Many had been robbed of hats, coats, and shoes, and in many instances stripped entirely naked.  One thousand seven hundred and ninety-nine Union soldiers were committed to graves, the best, in view of their condition, that could be given them.3)History of Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1861-5, Samuel P. Bates, page 378

Next morning we went to work with a will, in squads of twenty men.  On the second morning I found a lot of bodies among some elder bushes.  In the hand of one of those dead boys was a letter; I stooped down to take it and when I got up, a big Colt’s revolver was pointed at me.  All the Rebel had to say was, “Drop that letter, you damn Yank,” and I did.4)My Early Life and The Civil War, Conrad Smith, 1920, pg 24

The companies of the 139th took turns at the work.  Adjutant Albert Harper wrote a letter describing the scene on one of his breaks:

I am at the ground formerly occupied as the Hospital… I am now waiting until one of the company that has been gone… to return and then to detail another company for the very unpleasant duty to bury the dead of last Saturday’s battle.  Within 50 feet of me lat the bodies of 14 soldiers who have been dead so long that they are perfectly black and alive with maggots – the smell was terribly offensive but now… I have become accustomed to it and do not smell it excepting an occasional puff when the wind blows.5)“The Crack Regiment of Pittsburgh”, The Men and the Community of the 139th Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1860-1865, Sam Bartlett, April 12, 1996, page 82

Robert Guyton, of Company F, wrote home on September 10th relaying that on the 5th they made a march of “about twenty miles through the most desolate piece of country that I have ever seen… with dead horses and broken wagons and ammunitions [sic]of war.”6)Bartlett, page 81  When he got to the battlefield Guyton reported that there was one particular place where “there was seventy-five [men] buried in one pile… the rebels had stripped all our men and they were mortified and we found that it was impossible to move them and we just covered them over with dirt as they lay.”7)Bartlett, page 82

Major General D. B. Birney

Major General D. B. Birney

Despite being brand new soldiers and working under terrible conditions, Union General D. B. Birney was not happy with their work:

“I sent two officers and 50 men, with a wagon, loaded with shovels and picks to the Bull Run battlefield, to bury the dead.  It seems that the 139th Regiment Pennsylvania Volunteers, detailed for that duty, contented themselves with throwing a few clods of dirt over the dead, leaving them uncovered hands and feet.  The slight rains have since uncovered them.”8)Official Reports, Series I, Vol. XIX, Part I, page 1091

 

 

In his report to the Surgeon General of the Army in Washington of September 11, 1862, Medical Inspector Richard H. Cooper remarked:

A few ambulances were employed in conveying stores and food to the several field depots, and fresh beef was sent to Centreville.  From that moment trains of ambulances, each with food and stores, arrived in rapid succession.  The supply was superabundant.  The bread, which otherwise would have spoiled, and one of the beeves, which I did not need, and which I could not feed, were given to the 139th Pennsylvania, which had come to bury our dead, and had failed to bring rations.9)Official Reports, Series I, Vol. 19, Pt. II, page 263

But Albert Harper believed that some good came from the work.  “Bull Run,” he wrote, “had had a good effect on our men.  They look on death as quite a common thing and say they are anxious for a fight.”10)Bartlett, page 82

The day we came on the field, the Rebels took our money, watches and other junk and told us we would get it back when our work was done, but when we came off the field, we were told that the company that had it had left the day before. We went back to Camp Arlington absolutely broke. It was twenty-seven miles from Washington to Bull Run, so that was a march of fifty-four miles and three hard days work with very little rest at night. The ground was plenty soft enough to sleep on when we got back to camp.11)My Early Life and The Civil War, Conrad Smith, 1920, pg 24

References

References
1 Conrad’s dates do not always correspond with other sources.  He was writing this more than 50 years after the fact.
2 My Early Life and The Civil War, Conrad Smith, 1920 pg 23
3 History of Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1861-5, Samuel P. Bates, page 378
4, 11 My Early Life and The Civil War, Conrad Smith, 1920, pg 24
5 “The Crack Regiment of Pittsburgh”, The Men and the Community of the 139th Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1860-1865, Sam Bartlett, April 12, 1996, page 82
6 Bartlett, page 81
7, 10 Bartlett, page 82
8 Official Reports, Series I, Vol. XIX, Part I, page 1091
9 Official Reports, Series I, Vol. 19, Pt. II, page 263

6 thoughts on “Burying the Dead at Bull Run

  1. My great, great Grandfather David LeFevre Crawford was here. Eventually promoted to Adj.
    Does anyone know the source of the letter(s) of Albert Harper here. I have a copy of a letter to him by his brother Samuel Harper QM of the 139th PVI dated January 9, 1865 that also mentions my relative David Lefevre Crawford.
    Also, if anyone has run across any references to David L. Crawford of the 139th PVI, please share those with me.
    Thanks,
    David Scott Crawford

    • Hi David! Thanks for your question. My quotes from Albert Harper’s letters are taken from Sam Bartlett’s thesis “The Crack Regiment of Pittsburgh”: The Men and the Community of the 139th Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1860-1865, written in 1996. I obtained a copy from Amherst College with Mr. Bartlett’s permission. His bibliography lists, among others, the Harper Family papers, 1861-1865 located at the Library and Archives Division, Historical Society of Western Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh.

      The records I have show your ancestor in Company I. I am watching the pension files on http://www.Fold3.com but his (assuming he filed for one) is not yet digitized.

      Other references I have found in my research to David include:
      wounded at Petersburg March 25, 1865

      From Samuel Schoyer’s diary, entry for February 22, 1864:
      Grand time at the 102nd. Stayed in camp all day. Didn’t attend the R ball at the Ferry. Administered oath of abstinence to McGregor (James Maj 139th?) and Crawford (D. Le F. First Lt. Co E, later Adj?)…
      The information in the parenthesis appears to be added by the editor who was guessing this Crawford was your Crawford.

      Thank you for your comment. I will be happy to pass on any other information I find about your ancestor.

      Dianne

      • Dianne,
        Thank you for this helpful and informative response. Al and Samuel Harper knew and worked closely with DLC and discuss at length issues he and the other officers were having with Lt. Col. Parr of the 139th PVI. The letter I have have from Samuel Harper is most detailed and it would be fascinating to read other letters in the Harper family files from the CW period.
        An historian researching at the National Archives recently sent me a three page letter/statement from my ancestor as well as a court transcript involving him and Lt. Col. Parr.
        Your reply is much appreciated, and I would be very interested in reading Bartlett’s thesis “The Crack Regiment of Pittsburgh”
        Cheers,
        DSC

        • I only have Bartlett’s thesis in paper form. I will see about scanning it. I may need to check on copyright issues too.

          I would love copies of the documents you received from the National Archives.

  2. Dianne,
    I am very interested in your sources for the quotes above . . .as you know this portion of Conrad’s book have fascinated me . . .and your sources are the first ones that comment on it specifically. Would you mind putting the full bibliographical info on your blog (or email it to me separately), as I would like to look into them in more detail.

    Thanks

    Jim

    • Hi! The Official Reports can be found online at the Making of America website, http://ebooks.library.cornell.edu/m/moawar/. There are other sites where they can be accessed as well. I actually went to the Wichita Public Library and looked a the hard copies they have there. I paid to get a copy of Sam Bartlett’s thesis from Amherst College. I will send you his source list when I get home. You have a copy of Conrad’s book right?

      Dianne

Leave a Reply

I